The Conn Smythe Trophy found a deserving yet unconventional recipient on Monday night as Connor McDavid was crowned the playoff MVP, despite his Edmonton Oilers falling short in the Stanley Cup Final. McDavid’s performance throughout the postseason was nothing short of extraordinary, and his contributions did not go unnoticed, even in the face of defeat against the Florida Panthers.
A Season for the Ages
McDavid’s postseason heroics saw him accumulate an impressive 42 points, just five shy of the record 47 points set by Wayne Gretzky in 1985. Yet, the star center did not manage to find the net in the decisive Game 7. Despite this, his overall impact was profound, leaving an indelible mark on the 2023 playoffs.
“It’s incredible. There’s no shortage of words. He’s just so awesome. He brings it every single day, and when we need him the most, that’s when he plays the best. He’s obviously a really special player and a special guy, too,” said teammate Dylan Holloway, encapsulating the sentiment within the Oilers' locker room regarding McDavid’s influence.
A Rare Achievement
McDavid's accolade places him in unique company as he becomes only the second skater to win the Conn Smythe Trophy on a losing team in the Stanley Cup Final, a distinction he shares with Reggie Leach of the Flyers, who achieved the feat in 1976. The recognition of his prowess, even in defeat, speaks volumes about his exceptional capabilities.
The list of goaltenders who have accomplished this rare feat includes illustrious names such as Jean-Sebastien Giguere of Anaheim in 2003, Ron Hextall of Philadelphia in 1987, Glenn Hall of St. Louis in 1968, and Roger Crozier of Detroit in 1966. While the majority of Conn Smythe winners are typically on the victorious squad, McDavid’s selection highlights the magnitude of his performance throughout the playoffs.
Pivotal Moments
McDavid’s influence was particularly evident during critical moments, such as Game 4, where he delivered a masterclass performance by scoring a goal and providing three assists, leading Edmonton to an emphatic 8-1 victory. His relentless drive to succeed was further displayed in Game 5, where he tallied four points, including an empty-net goal, to help drag the series back to Alberta.
“He’s playing on a different level. I didn’t think it was possible for him to elevate his game, but he has,” remarked Nick Cousins, acknowledging McDavid’s unparalleled ability to rise to the occasion when it matters most.
Consistent Excellence
McDavid’s ability to perform at an elite level has been a hallmark of his career thus far. He has led the league in scoring five times during the regular season, earning accolades and setting benchmarks that solidify his status as one of the premier talents in the sport. However, the coveted Stanley Cup remains an elusive prize for the 26-year-old superstar.
Despite the absence of a championship, McDavid’s tenacity, skill, and leadership have drawn praise from teammates and opponents alike. “He’s very unique. He’s learned to be relentless, and he enjoys it and he’s very, very serious about his craft, and that becomes contagious when you’re on the team with him,” said Ken Hitchcock, shedding light on the intangible qualities that McDavid brings to the ice every night.
Leadership and Legacy
Beyond the numbers, perhaps what stands out most is McDavid’s leadership and the confidence he instills in his teammates. Goaltender Stuart Skinner spoke to this aspect, saying, “He gives me a ton of confidence no matter what happens in the game. Whether I let in five, whether I get a shutout, he’s always in my corner, he’s always patting me on the back and telling me that he believes in me. ... I could talk about him for a very long time.”
As the Oilers look to the future, McDavid’s influence will undoubtedly be a crucial factor in their quest for glory. His individual accolades, while impressive, are merely a testament to his broader aspirations for team success. Despite the setback in the Stanley Cup Final, McDavid’s exceptional playoff run has cemented his status as one of the game's greats, and his journey is far from over.